CALL US
02 9000 1115

LOCATION
Level 8, 65 York Street Sydney 2000

PHONE: 02 9000 1115

The Best Pricing Strategy for New Products: Undercharge or Overcharge? 💲

Key Takeaways

  • The best pricing strategy for new products balances customer value, market demand and profitability, not simply low prices to win market share.
  • A 1% decrease in average prices can reduce operating profit by approximately 8% for an average S&P 1500 company, assuming sales volumes and other factors remain unchanged. Overpricing, meanwhile, risks losing customers who do not see sufficient value.
  • Cost-plus and competitor-based pricing alone cannot capture a product’s full value. Businesses need value-based, customer-focused and dynamic pricing strategies.
  • The optimal price comes from understanding customers’ willingness to pay, testing the full price range and balancing margins with sales volume.

Many Australian businesses believe, either consciously or subconsciously, that the best pricing strategy for new products is to set a low price to penetrate the market. In doing so, they risk underselling the value of a new offer, even when the product delivers significant benefits to customers. Pricing strategy consulting can help businesses identify these mistakes, understand customer willingness to pay and develop pricing approaches that support sustainable profitability.


>Download Now: Free PDF How to Improve Product Pricing



Table of Contents:

I. The Best Pricing Strategy for New Products: Is It Better To Undercharge Or Overcharge New Consumer Goods?

II. Pricing Strategy: Organising a Business for Better Pricing Decisions

III. New Product Development Pricing Strategy: Bite-Size Yields Highest Prices


See whether your pricing is under control
the best pricing strategy for new products

The Best Pricing Strategy for New Products: Is It Better To Undercharge Or Overcharge New Consumer Goods?


Is undercharging for new consumer products and services right? No, but it’s certainly common. Many retailers risk underpricing new products when they rely too heavily on cost-plus calculations or competitor prices rather than understanding customer value and willingness to pay. Sometimes, businesses set prices so low that they lose money on each sale. This is clearly not a sustainable pricing strategy for new products.

Australian retailers across categories such as home improvement, electronics and department stores face different pricing challenges. A low-price strategy does not automatically translate into sustainable profitability. Even Amazon, which is known for its Everyday Low Pricing strategy, uses low prices to gain market share and share of wallet.

Amazon’s low-price strategy was supported by its scale, access to capital and long-term investment approach. Smaller businesses should be careful about copying this strategy without considering their own financial resources and profitability targets. Following Amazon’s lead may not be the best pricing strategy for new products unless a business has similar financial resources, access to capital and the ability to sustain lower margins over the longer term.

Introduction to Price Optimisation 💰 Podcast Ep. 74!

The Best Pricing Strategy for New Products: What Should Businesses Do?

The best pricing strategy for new products is to set a price that reflects customer value while protecting profitability. Avoid automatic underpricing to win market share and excessive pricing that customers do not see as fair value. Achieving this requires strong pricing capability, including the skills, data and processes needed to assess customer willingness to pay, evaluate market demand and make informed pricing decisions.

Before launching a product:

  • Assess the full price range, including the highest and lowest prices the market may accept.
  • Look beyond cost-plus and competitor-based pricing. Consider value-based, customer-focused and dynamic pricing.
  • Do not assume a low price will generate enough sales to offset lower margins. Customers still need to know about the offer, understand it and have a reason to buy.
  • Treat stated willingness to pay with care. What customers say they are willing to pay can differ from their actual purchasing behaviour.
  • Avoid setting the reference price too high. It may increase short-term revenue from a small group while putting off customers who do not see the value.

McKinsey’s pricing analysis found that a 1% increase in average prices could lift operating profit by approximately 8% for an average S&P 1500 company, assuming sales volumes remain unchanged. This illustrates the significant impact pricing decisions can have on profitability.

The goal is to find the optimal price that balances demand, customer value and profit. The following sections explain why businesses often miss that balance.

What’s the best pricing strategy for new products? 

If you, like me, are surprised by the extent of undercharging in Australia, you may be even more surprised to learn that many businesses don’t realise how much they are undercharging for new products.

That’s right; some businesses do not recognise the extent of their pricing problems because they lack the data, processes and capabilities needed to evaluate pricing performance.

They are undercharging customers because they use cost-plus mark-up pricing and/or believe that selling more products at lower prices will generate more revenue and market share. In reality, this is not necessarily the case.

Cost-plus pricing does not always result in undercharging. Sometimes, it produces an uncompetitive price that leads to declining sales or even zero sales. There’s absolutely no guarantee that low prices will generate more sales or increase sales volume. If low prices were all people were interested in, we would all:

  • Fly with low-cost airlines.
  • Shop at Aldi.
  • Drive Hyundai vehicles.
  • Choose the cheapest available accommodation.
  • Buy supermarket private-label products.
  • Purchase housewares from IKEA.

Which businesses do you think have the best pricing strategy for new products in Australia?

Businesses operating in industries with historically inelastic demand and limited competition often have greater pricing power. This can allow them to maintain higher prices and profitability, although it does not necessarily mean they have the best pricing strategies for new products. This is true if the ‘best’ pricing strategy is judged solely on profitability and share price.

But do they really have the ‘best’ pricing strategy for new products, or are they simply fortunate to dominate valuable industries with limited price competition and disruption?

Do you think banks and telcos set fair and profitable prices?

The best pricing strategy for new products sets prices that customers are willing to pay, rather than prices they must accept because they have no alternative. The right pricing strategy should reflect the value customers receive while allowing the business to generate sustainable revenue and profit.

Australia’s supermarket sector remains highly concentrated. The ACCC’s 2025 Supermarkets Inquiry found that the sector has an oligopolistic market structure, with Woolworths and Coles having limited incentives to compete vigorously on price. This highlights the importance of competition, market structure and pricing power when assessing supermarket profitability.

Businesses that consistently set high, profitable prices for new products tend to be leaders in their respective industries, often for many years. They also share several characteristics: relatively few competitors, standardised pricing structures and offers, limited customer choice, and significant regulatory pressure on pricing.

When demand is inelastic in Australia, prices tend to be high. What is more surprising is that some prices may approach, or even exceed, what customers are willing to pay.

What impact will excessively high prices have on leading Australian businesses, such as telecommunications companies, banks and supermarkets?

Businesses that have historically benefited from inelastic demand and limited competition, including fuel retailers, cigarette manufacturers, energy companies and Australian supermarkets, are now facing greater pricing pressure.

Customers want more value for their money and are demanding better customer service from their banks, telco operators and supermarkets. Excessively high prices are likely to have a negative, long-term impact on profitability and reputation in these industries. It’s possible that the ‘high price’ legacy enjoyed by so few for so long may be over.

Let’s take each of these high-priced industries one by one…

Banking

Fintech companies are moving into the transactional banking space, providing customer-focused solutions that improve payment services and digital wallets, an area traditionally dominated by banks.

Banks are responding by improving their IT systems and centralising transactions to make payments easier for customers. However, many of their systems remain difficult to use. It’s going to take time and lots of training to ensure staff and customers can use these new systems.

There are also a lot of charges and red tape. Customers have raised concerns about the quality and accessibility of advice from the Big Four banks, particularly when seeking support to manage their debt. Business owners seeking more specialised wealth management and investment advice may need to look beyond traditional branch banking services.

Telcos’ Pricing Challenges

The telecommunications market is also undergoing significant disruption. Telecommunications providers can differentiate themselves through simpler pricing structures, bundled services and flexible plans. However, these offers must deliver clear customer value while protecting margins.

Many Australian telecommunications providers continue to focus heavily on their core communications services, although some are expanding into broader technology solutions. Their offerings often include traditional voice and SMS services, restrictive data allowances, slow internet, limited options, complicated bundles, upgrade fees and hidden charges that customers increasingly find frustrating. 

Telecommunications providers need to reconsider their business models and pricing structures. T-Mobile’s Un-carrier strategy offers one example, removing annual service contracts, overage charges, unpredictable roaming fees and restrictive data allowances. The question is whether Telstra, Optus or another technology-driven operator will pursue a similarly customer-focused approach.

Australia’s telecommunications sector is likely to undergo significant changes in its pricing strategies for new products. Telecommunications providers may need to reconsider fragmented fee structures as customers increasingly expect simpler, more transparent pricing. Unit-based pricing may no longer be the most effective approach as the sector transforms.

Customers don’t like complex and confusing pricing plans and offers. They don’t want to pay hidden charges for no reason. They don’t like poor customer service whether online or offline. Furthermore, they are switching over to platform-based alternatives which make their lives easier.


>>>Read about: How CEOs make big pricing decisions


Supermarket Retailing

Major supermarkets, including Coles and Woolworths, are also undergoing significant transformation. Customers are increasingly dissatisfied with aspects of the traditional supermarket shopping experience, including:

  • Warehouse-style store layouts.
  • Basic store presentation and lighting.
  • Limited product choice in some categories.
  • Procurement practices that can place pressure on suppliers.
  • Extensive ranges of highly processed products.

Mainstream supermarket retailing needs to change. People are fed up with zone pricing. Some consumers are shifting a greater share of their grocery spending to Aldi, specialist retailers and independent businesses in response to price, product range and perceived value. Consumers are increasingly purchasing meat, vegetables and bakery products from specialist retailers and independent businesses.

Customers are increasingly shopping for groceries online and turning to retailers such as Harris Farm Markets and quality independent butchers. The traditional high-street retail model, once disrupted by warehouse-style supermarkets, is making a comeback. This shift in supermarket retailing is closely connected to Australia’s changing economic conditions.

Many Coles and Woolworths customers are facing greater pressure on household budgets, influencing where they shop and how much they spend.

Household financial circumstances vary considerably across Australia. Mortgage repayments, personal loans and everyday living costs can reduce disposable income, influencing how much consumers are willing or able to spend on groceries. This can increase price sensitivity and encourage shoppers to compare prices, switch retailers or choose lower-priced alternatives.

Australia’s population and economic conditions are changing significantly. What once was the best pricing strategy for new products is no longer the best. Time to change!


>>>Read about: Underpricing: How Charging the Wrong Price Is Destroying Your Business? 🏢


Undercharging customers for new products is not the way to go either.

Many otherwise viable businesses in Australia struggle or close because they fail to charge prices that reflect the value they deliver to customers. Many businesses are also reluctant to trial new pricing approaches because they fear how customers might respond or simply do not know where to start. 

Across retail, fashion, electronics, B2B industrial markets, building materials, stationery and office equipment, businesses routinely undervalue their products, even in highly commoditised categories such as pens and paper. Businesses in Australia, both big and small, are routinely undervaluing themselves. In turn, they set prices for new products that are far too low. They are educating their customers to ask for discounts and dismiss all the value they deliver.

Too much money is being left on the table. Businesses are either setting prices slightly higher or lower than their competitors or using an incremental cost-plus pricing approach.

These uninformed pricing practices cost businesses millions, if not billions, of dollars each year.

And let’s make no mistake either. This wide-scale undercharging in Australia is not down to a kind or benevolent act. All businesses want to make money, and rightly so; it is the basis of a capitalist system.

Many businesses do not realise they have a pricing problem. They are effectively underselling their new product offerings and losing hard-earned revenue, profit and price positioning in the process.

Is undercharging new products a big deal?

Some people may argue at this point that undercharging is not such a big deal. All you need to do is sell more stuff when prices are low, or if that doesn’t work, increase prices later on.

But it is a big deal…

A low price doesn’t guarantee people will buy from you en masse. People have to:

  1. Know of you.
  2. Be motivated to buy from you.
  3. Be informed about the offer.
  4. Have a problem they want to solve right now.

A low price for a new product doesn’t address any of these needs.

  • How much will you increase prices at a later date? 2-3%?
  • What are you using as your reference product?
  • Across which products and categories?
  • Will all price increases be the same across the board?
  • What if you’re already overcharging on some items and undercharging on others?
  • What is your backup plan if customers reject your prices?

McKinsey’s pricing analysis illustrates the impact of small price changes: a 1% decrease in average prices can reduce operating profit by approximately 8%, assuming sales volumes and other factors remain unchanged. The actual impact of undercharging a new product will depend on its costs, margins and demand.

Implications

It is no longer an option for big and small businesses to take an undisciplined approach to pricing. Serial undercharging and overcharging are creating more harm to bottom-line profitability than good.

Profitable pricing decisions require a broader approach than incremental cost-plus calculations. Cost-plus and competitor-based pricing can provide useful reference points, but they do not necessarily reflect customer value, willingness to pay or market demand.

You need to stop thinking about margin expansion just as a volume play or cost-cutting exercise. Instead, start thinking about how you are going to unlock the full value of your businesses and your people.

See how pricing breaks in practice

Tips to set the best prices for new products and services

  1. Asking customers directly what they are willing to pay does not always reveal their actual purchasing behaviour. Stated willingness to pay can differ from what customers are prepared to spend in a real buying situation. Businesses should therefore combine customer research with pricing experiments and observed purchasing data when assessing demand and setting prices.
  2. Setting an excessively low reference price might accelerate a new product’s penetration of the market. However, the resulting lower margins forgo future profits that a higher price could have captured once a customer base had been established.
  3. Setting an excessively high reference price might capture more revenue and margin in the short or even mid-term from a small group of customers. But, you’ll also isolate a large proportion of your customers who are A) not prepared to pay the high price you want and B) don’t see or understand the value that you are offering.

〉〉〉 Get Your FREE Pricing Audit  〉〉〉


Conclusion: Finding the Optimal Price for New Products

A close look at the Australian retail and consumer market highlights the importance of adopting a more scientific approach to pricing. Australian businesses (big and small) across the board need to get more scientific with their pricing. That is, if they want the best pricing strategy for new products to drive greater customer usage, revenue and margins. 

When you set prices too high, you’ll lose revenue and volume. Once you set prices too low, you may not even cover your costs. When businesses identify the optimal price, they can improve profitability while maintaining a price customers consider fair and reflective of the value they receive.

To achieve sustainable revenue and profit growth without unnecessarily sacrificing sales volume, businesses need to assess the full range of prices the market will accept before launching a new product or service.

What is the highest and the lowest prices you could charge before you set a price for a new product? Don’t know? You’ve got a pricing problem.

How can you set the best and most profitable price for a new product without losing volume or revenue? If you don’t know, you need a world class pricing manager to help you work this out.

Don’t want to do any of this? Remember, there’s no reason you should be undercharging for a new product and losing your hard-earned revenue, profit and market positioning. Or overcharging a new product and have people accuse you of price discrimination or price gouging.

⇑ Table of Contents


See whether your pricing is under control
the best pricing strategy for new products

Pricing Strategy: Organising a Business for Better Pricing Decisions


Every business wants to make better pricing decisions, including decisions about dynamic pricing models. However, in the heat of the moment, and sometimes without the right skills, support, information or time, we end up making only adequate decisions and quite a few mistakes when developing a business plan.

You need the Right Numbers for Pricing! 👍 Podcast Ep. 66!

How much do these decisions cost us? Consider their impact on pricing professionals’ careers (promotion and compensation), team performance (morale, productivity, job security and retention) and organisational outcomes (cost-cutting, workplace culture and pricing power).

Is there some way to avoid preventable pricing mistakes to improve pricing strategy? And, do all good pricing decisions have to lead back to buying very expensive pricing software solutions?

Research on Decision Architecture and Pricing Decisions

Google uses behavioural economics like “Choice Architecture” to motivate and adapt unhelpful patterns of thought. First they understand the underlying problem leading to unprofitable or unhealthy decisions. Then, they design the behavioural solution, which essentially “nudges” employees in a certain direction without, they claim, taking away their freedom to make decisions for themselves (a matter of debate, I think…).

As people, we like to think that we recognise when we make the wrong decisions. We like to think we know right from wrong in real-time. Many large organisations across industries understand how difficult real-time decision-making can be, particularly when decisions affect individuals, teams and business performance.

Research in behavioural science highlights how cognitive biases and established habits can influence the way people make decisions. These patterns can make it difficult to recognise mistakes and adopt alternative approaches.

We all (whether we like to admit it or not) rationalise, deny, blame and basically react in ways that push us away from the reality of our mistakes. Our ultimate comfort zone is to think we are righteous and magnanimous in most situations. However, our responses and subconscious behaviours (i.e., try thinking back to your 360 feedback from colleagues and customers for a moment if you are finding this difficult to believe) and even annual financial results can all indicate quite a different picture to the picture of reality we would hold firmly in our heads…

Pricing Recruitment For Pricing Managers!

Repeated habits can make pricing mistakes difficult to change.

Repeated behaviours can become established habits, making them difficult to change. In a business environment, this can make it harder for employees to recognise ineffective pricing practices and adopt better decision-making approaches. Consistent coaching, feedback and training can help teams develop more effective habits over time.

That is why “unlearning” is often a lot harder than learning, and why finding the right people with the right mindset is critical for building high functioning teams. The fewer bad habits a person has, the less unlearning needs to occur. Likewise, think very carefully about providing new recruits with targeted pricing and readiness training because it’s best to get the team on the right track early, before “bad habits” gain a competitive advantage and destructive team norms set in.


〉〉〉 Get Your FREE Pricing Audit  〉〉〉


The next question is: can we change our behaviour and overcome these patterns? Yes…

We can overcome our cognitive circuit breakers and make better decisions about pricing options in the following ways:

  1. Work in high-functioning pricing teams that coach and remind us of our strengths and goals.
  2. Encourage people with a performance mindset and learning agility to become the best version of themselves and make this the norm
  3. Recognise when people may not be suited to the new direction and provide appropriate support.
  4. Support compassionate leaders that know how to create positive environments in which people thrive.
  5. Choose to identify with ‘healthy’ organisations that value and care about people (not just profitability, hierarchy, or brand value).
  6. Accept that experimentation, learning from mistakes and adapting our approach are necessary to improve decision-making and achieve shared organisational goals.

Click here to download your free guide on pricing strategy.

⇑ Table of Contents


See whether your pricing is under control
the best pricing strategy for new products

New Product Development Pricing Strategy: Bite-Size Yields Highest Prices


What is the new product development pricing strategy of FMCG companies today?

In January 2019, the UK’s Office for National Statistics published an analysis of shrinkflation. It identified 206 products that had decreased in size between September 2015 and June 2017, while their prices generally remained unchanged in the month when the size reduction occurred. Shrinkflation affects various consumer goods, including food, household products and everyday essentials such as toilet paper, coffee and fruit juice.

Introduction to Price Optimisation 💰 Podcast Ep. 74!
  • Likewise, some toothpaste brands have started to sell in tubes that hold less and consequently cost more per millilitre.
  • Non-food categories have also experienced shrinkflation in Australia, particularly personal care and household consumables. Examples include toilet rolls, nappies, tissues, kitchen rolls and washing-up liquid.

Shrinkflation occurs when manufacturers reduce a product’s size, quantity or contents while maintaining or increasing its selling price. This increases the effective price per unit, although it does not necessarily guarantee higher profits.

But are shoppers really getting more value for money from this new product development pricing strategy? We’re interested in finding out how food manufacturers are able to implement this strategy to increase prices without most people realising they are paying substantially more each year for essentially less across nearly all types of food and non-food categories.

So, in this article, we’ll evaluate three different arguments for and against shrinkflation.

  • That food manufacturers are reducing pack sizes without reducing the price to increase profit.   
  • They are shrinking pack sizes for our convenience.
  • Food manufacturers are shrinking pack sizes for our health.

We’ll then discuss why food manufacturers are increasingly implementing shrinkflation. Is it because they care about consumers’ health (reducing sizes and controlling calorie intake)? Or are they just trying to cover their costs and make some profit on top? By the end of this article, you’ll learn exactly how and why food manufacturers are investing in shrinkflation as part of its new product development pricing strategy.

1. Food manufacturers are reducing pack sizes without reducing the price to increase profit.   

In July 2020, Mondelēz International announced plans to reduce the size of all Cadbury chocolate bars sold in UK multipacks, aiming to bring each bar below 200 calories by the end of 2021. The company said the list price would not change at the time, although retailers retained discretion over the final retail price. Mondelēz presented the changes as part of its portion-control and obesity-reduction commitments.

The move to cut pack sizes but not the price has been met with a backlash from some consumers and shoppers. People feel the timing is poor. As we know, many people are feeling huge financial pressure as a result of the COVID-19 crisis. For other consumers, however, this is a new topic and a phenomenon they just haven’t picked up on.

Mondelēz has stated that retailers determine the final selling prices of its products. The company does not necessarily intend to reduce its own list prices when product sizes change.

Some critics argue that food manufacturers are reducing pack sizes while maintaining prices simply to increase profitability. What’s more, they believe that they use market research to capitalise on human blind spots and weaknesses to maximise margins.

For example, food manufacturers spend millions of dollars each year trying to understand how visual cues impact shopper purchasing decisions. Notably, they have found that price and size are the two most important visual cues for shoppers.

On the matter of size, food manufacturers have learned from market research that very few shoppers examine the differences in weight for the same product over time. Rather, they find that most shoppers tend to assume pack sizes don’t change and are the same weight. What’s more, a lot of consumers are willing to pay a higher price, especially when they believe they are getting more value for their money.

Some manufacturers reduce the quantity of product inside a package while keeping the external packaging and selling price unchanged. In other cases, the packaging design may change, even when the product quantity is reduced.

For example, while it is common for the size of the package to stay the same after shrinkflation, often the design or picture on the package changes. Often this design change refers to the product’s ingredients. The packages now proclaim, ‘Now with added folate’ or ‘Proudly made with 100 per cent Australian ingredients.’

This change in design but not in price is intentional. Of course, as manufacturers do not want shoppers to think they are losing out on the change in any way. Also, they certainly don’t also want people to realise that they are actually paying more for less on their snacks. Even for their staple items like bread, milk and toilet paper.

Take Cadbury’s UK Creme Eggs as an example. In 2015, Mondelēz reduced the number of eggs in a multipack from six to five. Although the recommended retail price fell from £3.05 to £2.85, the price per egg increased from approximately 51p to 57p, representing an increase of around 12%. This demonstrates how reducing the quantity in a multipack can increase the effective price per unit, even when the overall pack price falls.

Shrinkflation can improve a manufacturer’s unit economics by reducing the quantity of product supplied while maintaining the selling price. This can increase revenue per unit of product and potentially reduce production costs. However, the actual impact on profitability depends on manufacturing costs, packaging, distribution and other operating expenses. All the while, the shopper is blissfully unaware that their favourite products are getting smaller and they are paying more.

Is this new product development pricing strategy of FMCG companies legal?

Australian Consumer Law requires businesses to avoid misleading consumers about product quantities, prices and other product representations. In addition, retailers covered by the Unit Pricing Code must display unit prices for applicable grocery products.

When a product’s quantity decreases while its selling price remains unchanged, its unit price increases, making it more expensive relative to the amount consumers receive. However, relatively few consumers in Australia notice shrinkflation, even though many pay attention to unit prices. And, even then, they do not keep track of how unit prices are increasing year on year. They tend only to note the absolute unit price and how it compares with a competing brand’s unit price. Then make a decision based on the differential.

For example, research shows that shoppers are more conscious of changes in prices and external pack size (as mentioned above) than changes in weight. What’s more, even a small increase in price can have a big effect on price-sensitive shoppers. Especially for shoppers that are already on the edge of choosing a cheaper brand based on size and price.

How do psychological price thresholds and unit prices influence purchasing decisions?

Shoppers often compare products using psychological price thresholds and unit prices. When a product’s price crosses a threshold that matters to them, they may become more likely to compare competing brands and consider alternatives. Their decisions can also depend on the products available, their immediate needs and the prices they see at the time of purchase.

Shrinkflation is not automatically unlawful in Australia. However, businesses must ensure that changes to product quantities, pricing information, labels and marketing representations comply with Australian Consumer Law and, where applicable, the Unit Pricing Code. Whether the practice is ethical is a separate question, particularly when customers are unlikely to notice that they are receiving less for the same price.

The distinction between commercial incentives and stated health objectives is central to the shrinkflation debate. The following sections examine whether smaller product sizes offer genuine convenience and health benefits to consumers.

Are food manufacturers now using health trends to justify higher prices for essentially reduced product? Does focusing on customer value drivers like health and convenience give food manufacturers the justification they’ve been looking for to extract more money from a customer segment already willing to pay more for their health?

Let’s look at these arguments in more detail to find out, starting with convenience.

2. Food manufacturers are shrinking pack sizes for our convenience

Although bite-size products are not new to the food industry, major brands continue to develop smaller packages designed for convenience and portability.

This makes it easier for people on the go. Changing lifestyles and consumer preferences have increased demand for convenient, portable food products, particularly those designed for immediate consumption.

Tyson, a major meat processor, for example, launched Hillshire Snacking, which offers packs of cut-up chicken that consumers can eat with their hands. Another example is Hormel, which created “Spam Snacks” in resealable bags. They serve up canned meat in bite-sized pieces. Kellogg’s also made their Kellogg’s To Go pouches with slightly larger pieces of cereal. The size is comparable to a bag of chips. The company says they’re “specifically created to be eaten by hand”. Even Hershey’s made snack mixes.

A part-time student and freelance writer in Wilmington stated, “I don’t like things that have to be assembled.” She said she picks snacks like protein bars and oranges that she can carry around in her purse.

Industry experts said that small snack packages are convenience items. And that they have one thing in common: they entice and satisfy consumers that want pre-portioned and portable snacks. Consumers don’t mind paying extra for products they see as making their lives easier.

3. Food manufacturers are shrinking pack sizes for our health

Consumer preferences around health, portion size and convenience can influence how food manufacturers develop and package their products.

Big companies such as Coca-Cola, Nabisco and McDonald’s have started to offer some of their products in smaller packages or servings. For example, Coca-Cola has introduced mini soda cans, while Nabisco offers Oreo Thins as an alternative to its original cookies. Food companies have introduced smaller portion sizes and alternative packaging formats in response to changing consumer preferences around convenience and portion control, especially for sugary drinks. However, the unit price is the same if not more expensive for these sugary drinks than ever before.

Some food manufacturers position smaller snack packages as a way to support portion control. However, consumers may also pay more per unit for individually packaged products that offer convenience or appeal to health-conscious preferences.

Let’s take Oreo, for instance. This is what gives consumers the understanding that mini cookies are “lighter” or are good for their diets.

The vice president for snacks at Pepperidge Farm foresees that the market for these small packages would undoubtedly double because they help consumers eat less without having to count their calorie intake.

Some consumers are willing to pay a premium for smaller, individually packaged snacks when they value portion control and convenience.

Some even think that 100 calories are too much for other diet-conscious customers. For example, Hershey’s created a 60-calorie chocolate bar and Jell-O also made 60-calorie pudding.

The assumption from food manufacturers now then is people think something is healthier when they see low-calorie food packages. However, smaller portions do not automatically make a product healthier. Nutritional quality and overall consumption still matter.

One shopper in Midtown Manhattan that bought Chips Ahoy said, “They’re pretty expensive, but they’re worth it. It’s individually packed for the amount I need, so I don’t go overboard.” She explained that the smaller Chips Ahoy packs helped her manage portion sizes. She also viewed the additional cost of 100-calorie packs as a convenience surcharge.

Discussion: Controversy on the Convenience and Health Reasons for the New Product Development Pricing Strategy

Does this new focus on health and convenience mean we’ll see a sugar and food tax added to our food bills for our convenience and health, of course? What’s more, will people actually be out in the streets campaigning for food tax to be added?

If that’s the case, new consumer insights generated by food manufacturers like Hershey and Mondelēz completely overturn traditional FMCG manufacturers’ assumptions about consumers. Many FMCG manufacturers for years believed it was not possible to raise prices straight out for their products. For many years now, most FMCG firms viewed consumers and shoppers as price-sensitive and themselves (i.e., what they were selling) as a commodity.

However, it looks like the real reason food manufacturers couldn’t raise prices (or only justified price increase using cost increases) in the past was because they didn’t have a customer or consumer-focused FMCG pricing strategy. When you sell junk food as healthy, it stops being a commodity and starts being a special treat, allowing FMCG firms to increase prices.

The commercial cost of ignoring changing consumer preferences can be significant, particularly when manufacturers fail to adapt their products, packaging and pricing strategies to evolving customer needs.

FMCG pricing decisions are closely connected to household spending patterns and changing consumer preferences. These shifts influence the products manufacturers develop, the pack sizes they offer and the prices consumers are willing to pay.

Consumers increasingly incorporate snacks into different eating occasions, creating opportunities for manufacturers to develop products that meet changing needs for convenience, portability and portion control.

Snacking represents a significant market opportunity for food manufacturers, with demand influenced by convenience, product variety and changing consumption habits. A 2024 USDA report, based on dietary data collected between 2017 and March 2020, found that 95% of US adults consumed at least one snack on a given day, while 78% consumed two or more. The findings indicate that approximately 5% of US adults did not consume a snack on a given day, while 17% consumed exactly one snack.

How about you, when was the last time you had a snack? Most probably, just a few hours ago. The latest is a day ago, I guess.

People no longer strictly eat during normal mealtimes, especially those with busy lifestyles. They nibble or snack when they get hungry. Some even skip regular meals altogether. As eating habits change, food businesses are finding new ways to turn familiar foods into convenient snacks. These include grilled chicken, cereal, chocolate, peanut butter and even Spam. Smaller packages make these products easier to carry and consume whenever and wherever customers want. Food in small packages or bite-size snacks come in handy.

See how pricing breaks in practice

Implications

The broader pricing question is how FMCG manufacturers balance changing consumer preferences with revenue and profitability objectives. This has several implications for the sector:

Most FMCGs just say they are reducing pack size and keeping prices the same or increasing prices because of increasing operational or commodity costs. They don’t tend to admit to making profitable revenue growth from price increases or consumer trends. Mondelēz is therefore a landmark case. What does this mean?

  • It looks like more FMCG will be using consumer data on key trends to justify price increases.
  • Mondelēz appears to be using consumer insights to inform its product and pricing decisions. However, its public announcement alone does not establish the sophistication of its internal pricing system.
  • It’s only a matter of time before other FMCG follow and do the same.
  • It looks like there are going to be a number of integrated transformations occurring in the FMCG sector soon.

〉〉〉 Get Your FREE Pricing Audit  〉〉〉


Bottom Line

Snacking represents an important consumption occasion and market opportunity for FMCG businesses. It can also represent an attractive commercial opportunity for food manufacturers and supermarket retailers. Whether ‘healthy snacking’ is really better for people’s health is debatable. However, the relationship between smaller snack portions and better health is not straightforward. Smaller packages do not necessarily improve nutritional quality or reduce overall consumption. In fact, bite-size snacks could in a way encourage unhealthier eating habits rather than healthier ones.

The FMCG companies that utilise evidence-based consumer and pricing insights to create and capture value evidently appear to be in the box seat. They’ll have mind share and market share. What’s more, they’ll be able to drive profitability by giving shoppers what they want, or what they think is good for them. What’s more, they may also find it easier to communicate price increases when product changes align with consumer priorities such as convenience, portion control and perceived value.

⇑ Table of Contents


For a comprehensive view and marketing research on integrating a high-performing capability team in your company, download our complimentary whitepaper on How to Improve Product Pricing.

Are you a business in need of help to align your pricing strategy, people and operations to deliver an immediate impact on profit?

If so, please call (+61) 2 9000 1115.

You can also email us at team@taylorwells.com.au if you have any further questions.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top