Whether you’re a company executive or a pricing professional, you’ve probably seen the highs and lows of market competition. You understand the fine line between remaining competitive and maintaining ethical practices. But what happens when those lines blur? This happened with four major potato companies that recently faced price-fixing cases.

 

>Download Now: Free PDF How FMCG Can Generate Profitable Growth Faster

 

The situation highlights a key issue for businesses of all sizes, especially those controlling significant market shares—avoiding the temptation to engage in price-fixing. Let’s dive into why price-fixing not only harms consumers but can also disrupt the success of businesses like yours.

 

Price-Fixing Cases of Alleged Potato Cartel in the US

 

In the U.S., McCain Foods, Cavendish Farms, Lamb Weston, and J.R. Simplot are accused of coordinating price hikes for frozen potato products like fries and tater tots. The lawsuit claims these companies swapped sensitive pricing data and even used covert communication channels to manipulate the market.

 

These companies collectively control 98% of the U.S. frozen potato market. This level of market power makes it easy to increase prices in lockstep, leaving consumers with fewer options and higher costs. While these allegations are yet to be proven in court, they serve as a cautionary tale for businesses globally—including here in Australia.

 

For companies like yours, who manage substantial market shares, it’s critical to avoid such practices. Price-fixing may seem like a shortcut to boost profits, but in the end, it disrupts the market and undermines trust—both with consumers and within the industry.

 

Capability Building Programmes For Pricing & Sales Teams!

 

What Is Price-Fixing? Is It Legal?

 

Price-fixing occurs when businesses agree to set their prices at a certain level, eliminating competition in the process. The result? Prices are kept artificially high, reducing the incentive for companies to innovate or improve their products.

 

At first glance, it might seem like a harmless strategy—aligning prices could even feel like an efficient way to maximise profits. But in reality, it stifles competition and damages the broader market. This is why price-fixing is illegal under antitrust laws, such as those enforced by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC).

 

By agreeing to keep prices at the same level, businesses inadvertently harm the consumer experience, limit innovation, and make it harder for smaller competitors to enter the market. For large players, it might even result in greater scrutiny from regulators, who are quick to identify these anti-competitive practices.

 

What Is A Chief Revenue Officer And What Should They Know About Pricing 🧑🏼‍💼 Podcast Ep. 110!

 

Why Group of Companies Fall into This Trap

 

Many established businesses—especially those with a significant market share—might assume that engaging in price coordination is a low-risk move. Some even believe that sharing information about pricing in casual industry discussions won’t cause harm. These assumptions are dangerous.

 

For instance, major players might be tempted to compare pricing data or align price increases with their competitors, thinking it’s a natural step in a competitive market. But this type of coordination, even if informal, crosses the line into price-fixing.

 

Another common mistake is the “everyone else is doing it” mentality. Large companies may feel justified in following the actions of competitors, fearing they’ll lose market share if they don’t. But this short-term thinking can lead to long-term damage, from hefty fines to tarnished reputations.

 

 

 

The Impact of Unethical Price-Fixing Cases

 

Let’s return to the potato case. If these price-fixing allegations are true, the consequences extend far beyond higher prices for consumers. Over time, such practices erode competition, which is essential for driving innovation and quality. It also undermines trust in the market, a crucial element for businesses seeking to build lasting relationships with customers.

 

Closer to home, something similar in Australia happened years ago with the bread price-fixing scandal. For years, major bread companies fixed prices, costing Australian consumers millions. These unethical practices not only hurt consumers but also impacted the market’s ability to evolve.

 

For companies like yours, the temptation to “follow the leader” can be strong. However, fostering fair competition is key to maintaining a healthy market. Without it, businesses—large and small—can become complacent, relying on inflated prices instead of improving value for customers.

 

Pricing Recruitment For Pricing Managers!

 

How to Avoid Price-Fixing Cases

 

To avoid the negative consequences of price-fixing cases, businesses need to rethink their approach to pricing. Rather than focusing on matching competitors, companies should emphasise value-driven pricing strategies that benefit both the consumer and the bottom line. Here are practical steps you can take:

 

Ensure Legal Compliance

Regularly review your pricing practices with legal experts to ensure they comply with ACCC guidelines. Proactive legal checks can help avoid costly mistakes.

Prioritise Transparency

Be clear about how your pricing is determined. When customers understand the value behind a price, they’re more likely to trust your brand.

Embrace Competition

Rather than fearing competition, view it as an opportunity to differentiate. Focus on improving product offerings, customer service, and innovation to remain competitive without resorting to price manipulation.

Avoid Informal Agreements

Be cautious in your interactions with competitors, especially in trade associations. Sharing sensitive pricing data, even informally, can raise red flags.

Invest in Value-Added Offerings

Ensure your pricing reflects the true value you provide to customers. Consumers are more likely to accept higher prices when they feel they’re getting something worthwhile in return.

 

〉〉〉 Get Your FREE Pricing Audit  〉〉〉

 

Building Ethical Businesses

 

The frozen potato scandal may seem distant, but it highlights an important lesson for established businesses in Australia. Price-fixing might offer short-term gains, but it harms the broader market, damages customer trust, and risks heavy regulatory penalties.

 

Building a business on ethical pricing principles fosters long-term growth. It creates an environment where innovation thrives, smaller competitors can compete, and consumers can trust your brand. So, rather than mimicking competitors, let’s focus on delivering value and fairness.

 

It’s important to stay ahead of the curve and avoid the pitfalls of price-fixing cases. If you want to discuss how these issues relate to your business or need guidance on implementing ethical pricing, feel free to reach out. We are here to help and would love to support you in building a fair, competitive pricing strategy that works for your business. Let’s talk soon!

 

For a comprehensive view of maximising growth in your company, Download a complimentary whitepaper on How FMCG Can Generate Profitable Growth Faster.

 

Are you a business in need of help aligning your pricing strategy, people and operations to deliver an immediate impact on profit?

If so, please call (+61) 2 9000 1115.

You can also email us at team@taylorwells.com.au if you have any further questions.

Make your pricing world-class!