Key Takeaways
- Modern insurance pricing requires more than cost-based models; insurers need to respond to changing customer behaviour, technology, competition, and market conditions.
- Improve pricing performance through customer and price segmentation, stronger new-business pricing, and tighter control of discounts.
- Align agent incentives and distribution objectives with retention, loss ratios, and long-term profitability rather than focusing only on new business.
- Incorporate customer price sensitivity, competitor pricing, and value drivers alongside claims data to build more effective pricing strategies.
- Strengthen pricing capabilities with better data, actuarial expertise, management oversight, and continuous testing of new pricing models.
Today’s insurance pricing models are no longer just a cost-plus game. Insurance companies must learn to adapt to new technological, market, and consumer complexities with better, more dynamic pricing if they want to maintain a competitive advantage in the industry.
>Download Now: Free PDF How to Drive Pricing Strategy to Maximise EBIT Growth
In this article, we will discuss the 6 steps that insurers can take to improve both insurance pricing strategy and price realisation. We call these actions the six processes for achieving pricing power in insurance.
6 Ways to Improve Your Insurance Pricing Process
Insurers can improve their pricing process by focusing on six practical areas:
- Upgrade portfolio price management by developing a deeper understanding of the client base, using customer and price segmentation to identify profitable opportunities.
- Polish new business pricing rather than relying on deep initial discounts that can create problems at renewal.
- Control the difference between list and customer invoice prices by reducing unnecessary discounts and linking discounting to agent performance.
- Harmonise distribution objectives with company-wide goals and pricing strategy so incentives support retention and long-term profitability, not simply new client acquisition.
- Add customer value drivers and competitor insights into pricing by considering client price sensitivity and prevailing market prices alongside claims experience.
- Reinforce the organisation’s infrastructure with strong actuarial capability, managerial oversight, better pricing processes, and the willingness to test and improve pricing systems.
Before we explore each step in detail, it’s important to understand how insurance pricing works and why these models matter to insurers.
Why Understanding Insurance Pricing Models Is Critical
Understanding insurance pricing models is a strategic necessity. These models determine how premiums are calculated, how risk is assessed, and ultimately, how capital is allocated to protect the business. Misunderstanding them can result in overpaying for coverage or, worse, leaving critical exposures underinsured.
Insurance pricing models typically consider factors such as historical claims data, risk exposures, market trends, and even behavioural patterns.
For example, a logistics company operating across flood-prone regions will face higher premiums under a risk-based model, while implementing proactive risk management measures could reduce costs.
Similarly, businesses with strong safety programs or robust compliance frameworks may leverage experience-based models to secure more favourable terms.
Beyond cost optimisation, understanding insurance pricing models supports strategic decision-making. Companies can use model insights to evaluate risk appetite, compare insurers effectively, and negotiate coverage structures that align with broader financial objectives.
Emerging models, such as parametric or AI-driven pricing, also allow businesses to anticipate claims scenarios and improve capital planning.
In a competitive environment, insurance is more than protection—it is a lever for efficiency and resilience. Analysing and actively engaging with insurance pricing models helps ensure premiums accurately reflect their risk profile, maintain operational continuity, and optimise financial performance.
For executives and risk managers, this knowledge transforms insurance from a compliance obligation into a deliberate, strategic tool.
What is unit pricing in insurance?
Rate making, or insurance pricing, is the process of setting charges or premiums by insurance companies. The benefit of rate making is to ensure a fair and adequate premium for clients, given the stiff competition in the insurance sector.
A rate is a price per unit of insurance for each exposure unit, which is the unit of measurement used in insurance pricing, whereas a pure premium refers to that portion of the rate needed to pay losses and loss-adjustment expenses.
Loading is the amount needed to cover other expenses like sales expenses and allow room to profit.
Technology disruptors revising insurance pricing strategy
As you know, technology has already disrupted many industries; the same is true for insurers’ pricing strategies, insurance pricing models, profit realisation, and ability to compete.
Other examples are the ever-changing collection of price and feature-comparing websites available to us now. All of these empower us to compare and review insurance products by price, value, and benefits.
You can also consider Solvency II, the EU regulatory framework that requires insurers to hold capital in relation to their risk profiles. These capital and risk management requirements can influence insurers’ pricing and profitability decisions.
In addition, the internet and new insurance platforms provide us with insight into how to effectively match a product choice with our unique needs and willingness to pay; we can increasingly act as our own insurance broker.
Capability Building Programmes For Pricing & Sales Teams!
Insurance pricing is now more effective and more transparent in terms of value. Though technology has made consumers more informed and price-savvy, they are more receptive to new price policies, offers as well as aware of security, mobility, and different types of coverage.
All of these developments, innovations and policies have in turn created the need for new price policies and dynamic pricing structures.
6 Steps to Building a Better Insurance Pricing Process
Fortunately, there are steps that insurers can take to improve both pricing strategy and price realisation in a changing technology-driven world. We call these actions the six processes to pricing power in insurance.
Introduction to Price Optimisation 💰 Podcast Ep. 74!
1. Upgrading portfolio price management
In order to maximise retention of the most profitable clients and to improve the profitability of low-value clients, insurers must achieve a deeper understanding of their own client base.
Many big insurers are developing more granular customer and price segmentation. Generating deep client insight from comprehensive data collection is essential for adding higher-margin auxiliary coverage alongside principal policies.
2. Polishing new business pricing
Initially, insurers tended to offer deep discounts to clients in the hope that this would ease the pain of the inevitable price increase at renewal time. But this method has been proven to be ineffective.
The industry has learned from data gathered not only from its own customer base but also from the buying habits of other insurance buyers.
As a result, some big insurers are optimising their pricing of new business. This includes strengthening risk management practices so they don’t get financially crippled by clients who decide not to renew their insurance policy.
3. Controlling the difference between list and customer invoice prices
Insurance sales agents tend to give huge discounts to meet their quotas. This has led to a distorted overall pricing structure and the generation of unprofitable portfolios.
Removing the discrepancies between the RRP, rating structure, and actual customer invoice price is essential, especially for a business whose profitability is driven by agents and brokers. Controlling discounts and linking them to the agent’s overall performance will improve the sustainability of the insurance firm.
4. Harmonising distribution objectives with company-wide goals and pricing strategy
Many insurance firms link insurers’ incentives to performance. But most evaluations are based on recruiting new clients rather than policy renewals. This results in a lack of focus on retention and long-term profitability.
The industry needs to re-evaluate its incentives based on the bottom line (loss ratio) as well as on the top line.
This includes giving agents additional options such as alternatives to monetary discounts (including higher deductibles, free supplementary coverage, and vouchers for future renewals), training staff on how to use first-rate customer-relationship-management systems to retain their best customers, and providing regular updates on how to provide the best possible sales experience.
5. Adding customer value drivers and competitor insights into pricing
Most insurers set their cost-oriented pricing structures on claims experience. To improve their pricing strategy, they must incorporate client price sensitivity and prevailing market prices (those of competitors) into their own pricing too.
Some would complain that regulations prevent them from allowing demand-based pricing or that their agents do not like it. A 2012 Boston Consulting Group report found that some insurers had developed innovative ways to work within regulatory frameworks, earning returns of up to 5 per cent of gross written premiums.
6. Reinforcing the organisation’s infrastructure
That means having a strong actuarial team, as well as strong managerial oversight capable of translating the business strategy into a disciplined pricing strategy.
Insurers need to revise their pricing processes, including a better dialogue among the management team to truly understand, monitor, and critique the work of the insurance agents. Updating their pricing systems requires boldness and willingness to try new systems, conduct pricing tests, and challenge common practices.
More Discussion on Insurance Pricing Models
Technological disruptors like Big Data, the Internet of Things, and predictive data analysis tools are giving the insurance industry the means to design usage-based and other innovative pricing models.
These new insurance pricing models and strategies gather data from new, external sources and estimate insurance pricing risk or consumer willingness to pay, buy, or churn more accurately. During the underwriting phase, they can also identify fraudulent applicants more precisely.
The problem for some insurance companies, it seems, has been caused by antiquated systems and misaligned operations. The problem lies in an analogue world where insurance rates are hard to precisely fit to the individual’s demands.
So, setting the right insurance policy for the client is basically speculating what kind of insurance the client needs.
Larger insurance companies have actuarial departments that maintain their own databases. These departments estimate the frequency and the dollar amount of losses for each underwriting class. But smaller companies rely on advisory organisations or actuarial consulting firms for loss information.
The new insurance pricing models can cater to demand more precisely so that customers are no longer obliged to buy the other insurance options they do not need. This unbundling makes companies vulnerable to disruption, specifically if they cross-subsidise parts of their offering, as insurers do, with direct sales channels.
Most insurance companies have only upgraded to a level of sophistication sufficient to deliver their intended pricing strategy.
Customers are also increasingly discerning and price-sensitive when they buy insurance products. The entry of new players and price aggregators has further driven prices down. This has led to customers looking for cheaper and cheaper deals. Now, parts of the insurance market are facing increasing commoditisation.
Tips on starting new insurance pricing models
Before insurance firms implement a new pricing strategy, they should ask the following questions:
- Is our pricing strategy giving us all the advantages it should?
- Do we really understand the dynamics of consumers’ responses to price changes?
- Do we have the organisational abilities to bring about a pricing step change, one that will give us a remarkable edge over our rivals?
- What investments should we make so that we can close any gaps in our pricing capabilities?
Insurers that can answer these questions honestly will very likely find themselves benefiting from their efforts. They will be on the same level as their customers and will be able to react accordingly with pricing moves.
In addition, they will also know which actions will give them the best result. On the other hand, insurers that do not take the necessary action will end up playing a guessing game that will decrease their pricing power moving forward.
Pricing Recruitment For Pricing Managers!
Implications
- Customers are increasingly informed and price-sensitive. Insurers must find other pricing methods that are aligned to digital.
- The entry of direct players and price aggregators has meant greater transparency. This means that it has enabled customers to choose the least expensive deal on their own terms.
- Many insurers are still tempted to attract clients with initial deep discounts. They are, after all, hoping for a higher insurance renewal price when renewing the policy. But this strategy is proving increasingly ineffective.
〉〉〉 Get Your FREE Pricing Audit 〉〉〉
Bottom Line
In this article, we discussed insurers that take the initiative to address the many pricing-related challenges. Only some insurers demonstrating good value-based pricing will reap the rewards in the years to come.
We believe that insurers that fail to take action may end up playing a guessing game, one that will diminish their pricing power going forward.
Insurers with the best teams and systems to generate comprehensible data from deep client insight will lead the market. This is particularly important for identifying prospects for cross-selling and/or adding higher-margin auxiliary coverage alongside their principal policies.
Click here to access a free guide on building an effective pricing capability today.
For a comprehensive view on maximising growth in your company, Download a complimentary whitepaper on How To Drive Pricing Strategy To Maximise EBIT Growth.
Are you a business in need of help to align your pricing strategy, people and operations to deliver an immediate impact on profit?
If so, please call (+61) 2 9000 1115.
You can also email us at team@taylorwells.com.au if you have any further questions.
Make your pricing world-class!
