Navigating the intricate landscape of pricing amidst regulatory shifts is a perpetual business imperative. Coles, currently under scrutiny for its price increase adjustments linked to the Container Deposit Scheme (CDS Vic), vividly illustrates the nuanced challenges that businesses confront. Aligning pricing strategies with evolving environmental initiatives demands a delicate balance, requiring companies to adeptly address operational demands, consumer expectations, and regulatory compliance to sustain profitability and positive public perception.


>Download Now: Free PDF How to Improve Your Pricing Team Performance


The repercussions of Coles’ choice to raise prices in light of the CDS Vic have ignited a wave of discontent among consumers. This backlash not only amplifies worries about potential repercussions on customer satisfaction but also casts a shadow over the perceived environmental advantages promised by the scheme. This situation poses a pressing dilemma for businesses, highlighting the intricate challenge of harmonising compliance with evolving regulations without compromising the delicate equilibrium between customer loyalty and sustained profitability.


In this article, we are going to discuss the Coles price increase predicament, offering insights and practical suggestions for navigating such scenarios in today’s market. First, we’ll delve into the specifics of Coles’ decision to increase prices in response to the Container Deposit Scheme (CDS Vic). Then, we’ll analyse the implications of this strategy on consumer perception and loyalty. We argue that transparent communication and a customer-centric approach are essential in mitigating potential backlash and maintaining a positive brand image.


At Taylor Wells, we believe that businesses facing similar challenges can draw valuable lessons from Coles’ experience. By the end, you will understand the broader implications for businesses seeking to harmonise compliance, customer satisfaction, and profitability in the ever-evolving market landscape.



Analysis Of Coles Price Increase Strategy Amid The 10 cent Container Deposit Scheme


Coles, a key player in the retail sector, recently enacted price adjustments on specific items in response to the initiation of the Container Deposit Scheme (CDS Vic) in Victoria. This environmental initiative encourages recycling by offering a 10-cent refund for each eligible item returned.


However, this seemingly eco-friendly move has stirred discontent among consumers, who have labelled Coles as a “cartel pretending to be a supermarket.”


This situation underscores the intricate balancing act that businesses, particularly in the retail domain, must master. On one hand, there’s the pressing need to align with evolving environmental regulations, such as the CDS Vic, reflecting a commitment to sustainability. On the other, maintaining customer satisfaction and ensuring profitability remains paramount.


For Coles, the pricing adjustments reflect an attempt to cope with the operational expenses tied to the CDS Vic. This strategic move, however, has triggered skepticism among consumers, raising questions about transparency and the true motivation behind the price hikes.


While the CDS Vic represents a positive step toward fostering a recycling culture, the associated costs have led to an unintended consequence for Coles—a potential dent in its customer-centric image.



Examining Coles’ pricing strategy in light of the Container Deposit Scheme (CDS Vic) reveals a deliberate response to the associated operational expenses. However, questions emerge regarding transparency and effective consumer communication. Rather than entirely absorbing the recycling costs, Coles chose to transfer a portion of them to consumers—a practice not uncommon in the retail sector but one that has sparked criticism


Businesses operating in a similar landscape can draw valuable lessons from Coles’ scenario. Firstly, transparent communication is key. Clearly outlining the rationale behind pricing adjustments, especially in the context of environmental initiatives, can help build trust with consumers.


Secondly, understanding the pulse of the customer base is crucial. Coles’ situation emphasises the need for businesses to gauge customer sentiment accurately, ensuring that pricing decisions align with consumer expectations.


Is Coles Price Increase Strategy A Good Example Of Supermarket Business Financial Management?


Coles’ strategic decision, while attempting to navigate the financial implications of the CDS Vic, raises concerns about how it might impact customer loyalty and public perception. Businesses can glean valuable insights from Coles’ approach, understanding the delicate balance required when managing pricing strategies amidst regulatory changes.


coles price increase


For instance, if Coles had proactively communicated the specific products affected by the price increases and elucidated the rationale behind the decision, it could have potentially mitigated the backlash. This underscores the importance of businesses being transparent and strategic in their pricing adjustments, considering the potential repercussions on customer trust and overall brand image.


How can Coles navigate this price increase conundrum?


Coles should consider adopting a value-based and customer-centric approach. This not only addresses the immediate challenges posed by the pricing adjustments but also positions Coles as a socially responsible and customer-focused retailer in the eyes of its consumers.


1. Transparent Communication


To address the pricing challenge effectively, Coles should initiate a transparent communication strategy. This involves openly and clearly communicating to consumers which specific products will be subject to price increases.


By providing this information, Coles not only demonstrates a commitment to honesty but also fosters clarity and trust among its customer base. Transparent communication is pivotal in preventing misunderstandings and mitigating potential backlash.


For example, Coles could issue a comprehensive statement or use in-store signage and digital channels to convey the specific items affected by the price adjustments. By proactively sharing this information, Coles ensures that customers are well-informed, reducing the likelihood of negative reactions.


2. Tiered Pricing Structures Linked to the 10-cent Refund


Coles can further enhance its pricing strategy by implementing tiered pricing structures directly tied to the 10-cent refund offered by the Container Deposit Scheme (CDS Vic). This step not only aligns with environmental goals but also serves to mitigate customer dissatisfaction.


For instance, Coles could introduce pricing tiers based on the recyclability or environmental impact of products. Items with higher recycling potential or lower environmental impact could be priced more competitively, creating an incentive for customers to choose environmentally friendly options.


This approach not only supports the overarching goal of the CDS Vic but also positions Coles as an environmentally conscious retailer, potentially attracting a more environmentally aware customer base.



3. Loyalty Incentives for Eco-Friendly Products


In addition to transparent communication and tiered pricing, Coles can solidify its customer-centric approach by offering loyalty incentives, specifically discounts on eco-friendly products. By doing so, Coles not only aligns its pricing strategy with consumer values but also encourages sustainable purchasing behaviour among its customer base.


For example, Coles could introduce a loyalty program where customers receive discounts or special offers on products with eco-friendly packaging or those eligible for the 10-cent refund under the CDS Vic. This not only rewards environmentally conscious purchasing but also reinforces Coles’ commitment to sustainability.


Such loyalty incentives not only contribute to customer satisfaction but also position Coles as a retailer actively promoting positive environmental practices.


What can other businesses learn from this case study on the price increase of Coles?


This case study imparts a crucial lesson for businesses: the paramount importance of harmonising pricing strategies with both regulatory requirements and customer expectations. To achieve this delicate equilibrium, businesses should proactively communicate changes, fostering transparency to build and maintain trust.


The essence lies in striking a strategic balance between compliance with evolving regulations and ensuring customer satisfaction—a synergy that paves the way for enduring success in the dynamic marketplace. By heeding this lesson, businesses can navigate pricing challenges with agility, preserving their reputation and customer relationships.



Implications Of Strategies For Effective Price Increase And Financial Management In Supermarket Business


Optimising pricing mechanisms requires continuous evaluation of market dynamics, regulatory landscapes, and customer sentiment. Businesses must remain agile, adjusting pricing strategies to align with evolving conditions while considering the broader impact on their customer base.


Establishing a high-performance pricing team is imperative for navigating complex pricing challenges. A dedicated team can assess market trends, regulatory changes, and customer feedback, informing strategic pricing decisions that enhance both compliance and customer satisfaction.


Our findings show that with the right set-up and pricing team in place, incremental earnings gains can begin to occur in less than 12 weeks. After 6 months, the team can capture at least 1.0-3.25% more margin using better price management processes. After 9-12 months, businesses often generate between 7-11% additional margin each year as they identify more complex and previously unrealised opportunities, efficiencies, and risks.


Embedding commercial capability throughout the organisation ensures that every department understands and contributes to the pricing strategy. This holistic approach fosters alignment with business objectives, enabling seamless integration of pricing decisions with broader organisational goals.


Our findings show that when a business builds and embeds commercial capability across the business; bolstering its internal pricing skills and capabilities to build a sustainable pricing system, it can generate at least 3-10% additional margin each year while protecting hard-earned revenue and volume. This is at least a 30-60% profit improvement straight to the bottom line.


〉〉〉 Get Your FREE Pricing Audit  〉〉〉


Bottom Line


Coles’ response to the Container Deposit Scheme (CDS Vic) pricing challenges unveils the intricate dance businesses must perform to align with environmental initiatives.


The case underscores the pivotal trifecta of regulatory compliance, customer satisfaction, and profitability, showcasing the delicate balance needed for success in the dynamic retail sector. Coles’ decision to pass on recycling costs to consumers, though common, sparked skepticism, emphasising the critical role of transparent communication in navigating pricing adjustments.


The proposed value-based and customer-centric pricing suggestions provide Coles with a comprehensive strategy. Transparent communication, coupled with tiered pricing structures and loyalty incentives for eco-friendly products, positions Coles as a socially responsible and customer-focused retailer. These approaches not only address immediate pricing challenges but also contribute to long-term sustainability and positive brand perception.


For businesses at large, the case study imparts essential lessons: the necessity of aligning pricing strategies with regulatory changes and customer expectations. Proactive communication, transparency, and the delicate balance between compliance and customer satisfaction emerge as guiding principles for enduring success in the ever-evolving business landscape.


Coles’ experience serves as a beacon, advocating for thoughtful integration of environmental responsibility, consumer-centricity, and operational adaptability in pricing strategies as businesses navigate the complexities of the modern marketplace.


For a comprehensive view of integrating a high-performing pricing team in your company, Download a complimentary whitepaper on How to Improve Your Pricing Team Performance.


Are you a business in need of help aligning your pricing strategy, people and operations to deliver an immediate impact on profit?

If so, please call (+61) 2 9000 1115.

You can also email us at if you have any further questions.

Make your pricing world-class!