How to Make a Price Match Strategy Work Without Sacrificing Profits 🥊

Suppose you own a small corner shop in suburban Melbourne. A loyal customer comes in, holding their phone. “I saw this same jar of peanut butter cheaper at Aldi. Can you match the price?” You hesitate, knowing that saying no might lose their trust. But agreeing means cutting into your already tight margins. This scenario, while hypothetical, is a reality for many businesses. A price match strategy might be easy to promise but tricky to pull off.

>Download Now: Free PDF How FMCG Can Generate Profitable Growth Faster

Let’s explore why businesses adopt price-matching, the challenges it brings, and how you can rethink this approach for sustainable success.

Why Retailers Do a Price Match Strategy

A price match strategy aims to keep customers from wandering to competitors. Major supermarkets, like Sainsbury’s in the UK, have extended their price-match schemes to smaller stores. Sainsbury’s matches Aldi’s prices on 200 essentials, hoping to lure price-conscious shoppers. This tactic is bold, considering smaller stores usually have higher operating costs.

In Australia, supermarkets like Coles and Woolworths might be tempted to follow suit, especially as Aldi solidifies its reputation for value. Price-matching on everyday items—milk, bread, vegetables—makes headlines and appeals to struggling families. It feels like a win-win: businesses appear customer-focused, and shoppers save a few dollars.

But is it really that simple?

The Hidden Costs of a Price Match Strategy in Groceries

A price match strategy can quickly become a slippery slope, especially for small businesses. Imagine competing with Aldi’s razor-thin prices while juggling rent, wages, and electricity bills. Supermarkets like Sainsbury’s may have deep pockets to absorb losses, but smaller businesses don’t have that luxury.

Here’s the catch: matching a competitor’s price doesn’t mean you’re matching their cost structure. Aldi operates efficiently, benefiting from economies of scale and no-frills store designs. When a small shop owner mirrors Aldi’s prices, they often take a loss, hoping customer loyalty will make up the difference.

However, loyalty isn’t guaranteed. Consumers may jump to the next shop offering an even lower price. This creates a cycle of diminishing returns, where businesses sacrifice profitability for a fleeting competitive edge.

Common Mistakes Retailers Make About Price-Matching Groceries

Many business owners assume a price match strategy guarantees customer retention. But in reality, it’s not always about price. People choose Aldi not just for affordability but for perceived value. If your business doesn’t offer that same value—whether through quality, service, or convenience—price alone won’t win the battle.

Another mistake is underestimating the psychological toll on business owners. Constantly tracking competitors’ prices can be exhausting and distract from bigger goals, like improving product quality or customer experience.

Consider Sainsbury’s customers who rely on smaller stores. They may appreciate price-matching, but many still miss out on discounts available in larger supermarkets. This inconsistency can leave customers feeling short-changed.

When to Implement Price Match and When Not to

Price matching isn’t inherently good or bad. It’s about context and execution. So, when should you do it?

Price-matching works well when:

You have a strong competitive edge. If your business offers superior service, convenience, or a unique experience alongside matched prices, customers are more likely to stick around.

You’re targeting high-demand essentials. Items like milk or bread can be strategically price-matched to attract foot traffic while maintaining higher margins on other products.

It’s part of a broader strategy. Price-matching should complement a larger plan, like building brand trust or boosting loyalty through quality and service.

However, price-matching isn’t ideal when:

It hurts your bottom line. If matching a competitor’s price on a key product cuts deeply into profits, it might not be worth it.

Your quality doesn’t stack up. Customers quickly spot when price-matched items are of lower quality, which can harm your brand.

It creates unrealistic expectations. Once you match prices, customers might expect it to apply to all products, making it harder to maintain margins.

Actionable Steps for Sustainable Price Match Policies 

If you’re considering price-matching or already use it, here are some practical tips:

Know Your Costs: Before committing to price-matching, ensure you fully understand your margins. Can you afford to sell certain items at a loss without compromising your business?

Focus on Value, Not Just Price: Customers don’t always want the cheapest option—they want the best value. Highlight what sets you apart: superior quality, exceptional service, or ethical sourcing.

Communicate Transparently: If you can’t match a price, explain why. Share your story. Customers appreciate honesty and are often willing to support local businesses when they understand the bigger picture.

Offer Exclusive Perks: Instead of matching prices, create your own value. Loyalty programs, personalised discounts, or free local delivery can build stronger connections than shaving a few cents off a product.

Reassess Regularly: Pricing strategies aren’t set in stone. Monitor their impact, gather feedback, and adjust based on what works for your business and customers.

〉〉〉 Get Your FREE Pricing Audit  〉〉〉

A Better Way for Retailers and Supermarkets to Win Customers

Imagine your shop becoming a community hub where customers trust you for quality, not bargains. They choose your peanut butter because it tastes better, supports local farmers, and aligns with their values. That emotional connection is priceless.

Price-matching may seem like a quick win, but it’s rarely the best long-term strategy, especially for small businesses. By focusing on value and building trust, you can rise above the price wars and create a business that thrives in any market.

So, the next time a customer asks for a price match, think about what you truly offer. Maybe the right answer isn’t, “Yes, we can match that,” but instead, “Here’s why we’re worth it.”

Take a moment to think about what works best for your business and your customers. Every decision counts, and it’s okay to ask for guidance. If you’re unsure where to start or want to explore your options further, let’s talk. Together, we can find a pricing strategy that makes sense for you. Reach out today—your success is worth it!

For a comprehensive view of maximising growth in your company, Download a complimentary whitepaper on How FMCG Can Generate Profitable Growth Faster.

Are you a business in need of help aligning your pricing strategy, people and operations to deliver an immediate impact on profit?

If so, please call (+61) 2 9000 1115.

You can also email us at team@taylorwells.com.au if you have any further questions.

Make your pricing world-class!