Why Blockbuster Went Out of Business? 🎦 An Analysis of its Business and Pricing Model
Why Blockbuster went out of business? It was one of the biggest video rental retailers in the country. It had branches from other countries as well. So what went so wrong?
Missing the days when after a long day at work, you’d look forward to watching the latest videos on your DVD player – and eating some popcorn while watching. In those days, we didn’t have streaming service; the internet was still in its infancy. The fastest speed back then was less than 3kbps and the modem was a dial-up phone line.
If you wanted to watch a movie at home you’d go to the nearest Blockbuster store and rent a DVD. In the store, you’d get a vast selection to choose from the old black and white classics like ‘Casablanca’ or the three-hour-long ‘Gone With the Wind’ to the latest ‘Star Wars’ prequel movies such as ‘Attack of the Clones.’ They also had a popcorn store so you didn’t have to go to the convenience store to buy it. All your viewing and snacking needs were in one store.
Blockbuster then was the biggest video rental company. They were also extremely popular: It had 84,300 people employed worldwide, that’s about 58,500 in the United States and about 25,800 in other countries. It had 9,094 stores in total, with more than 4,500 of these in the US.
Its net income was US$268 million in 2010, with revenue at US$3.24 billion. It was so successful then, it was featured in numerous movies. But in late 2010, they filed a Chapter 11 for bankruptcy. So what happened to it?
The standard analogue business model
Its strategy for the video rental store is to pay a big flat fee to the movie studios for $65 per title and give unlimited rentals for the duration of the DVD or videotape itself.
Blockbuster was obsessed with the new releases. They knew more people would rent the new movies because generally, it wouldn’t be available to buy in-store for a further 28 days. The customers had the option to rent, wait or buy the movie on DVD before the general release which costs around $70-$100 per title. This is substantially pricier than the suggested retail price.
The original strategy required a huge CAPEX budget. Its main strategy was to open as many stores it could all over the country. That way it could gain a huge chunk of the market. This strategy did work for a period of time, but it also incurred huge operating costs. More stores meant more rental spaces and more people to hire. Also, it proved to be harder to keep track of revenues on each and every store. So Blockbuster introduced another plan, which was to acquire more new movie releases and regulate the old ones to the back of the store. That limited shelf space for the old titles; and the new titles were of limited supply.
Losing Credibility – One Reason Why Blockbuster Went Out of Business
The mistake with this last business decision was that Blockbuster underestimated how much people wanted the old titles. It also frustrated people that the new titles were not readily available and they’d often leave without getting the titles they wanted. This lead to high levels of customer dissatisfaction. Customers routinely waited in line for new movie titles. Only to find they’d have to wait for another customer to return the DVD. In essence, it lost its credibility and customers. This is why Blockbuster went out of business. Customers were willing to pay for old and new movies but were unable to spend their money on movies they wanted to see.
Another reason why Blockbuster went out of business was its obsession with late fees. Late fees accounted for more than 15% of Blockbuster’s revenue during the retailer’s heyday. When a customer returned a DVD late, they were hit with a substantial late fee. A standard late fee is $1-per-day that will be added for every movie title if it is late, for up to 10 days. This $1 per day charge also applies to Blu-ray rentals as well. The company didn’t care what the customers had to say about the late fees. They just had to pay up, and not get what they wanted.
Not understanding the customers’ needs – Another Reason Why Blockbuster Went Out of Business
Not listening or acknowledging customers was another reason why Blockbuster went out of business. Successful online entertainment service businesses like Netflix or Stan value customer feedback and actively seek it to learn and improve. In fact, Netflix makes a habit out of getting feedback from their subscribers and then turning it around to improve their business, pricing and services model. A key reason why Blockbuster went out of business, then, was because they were disconnected from their customers and the market. They also didn’t value their customers or care about their feedback.
Another reason for their eventual demise was their failure to lower prices across all top-selling categories (movies, snacks and beverages).
Blockbuster charged too much for the DVD rentals which opened up lots of room for competition. Renting a video from Blockbuster, for example, cost around $2-$5 depending on the release date of the film, whether in the same year or before. And customers had to return the DVD on a set time and date. They charge a penalty for late returns. Those late fees comprised 70% of the company’s profits.
Netflix and Redbox, the DVD kiosk, on the other hand, only charged $1 per title compared to Blockbuster’s $5 in the United States. And in Australia, it’s AUD$2.99 for new releases and AUD $1.99 for older films for the same title. And the convenience of delivering or streaming at home – all the movie titles they wanted – made a very attractive offer.
In the end, to stay competitive, Blockbuster lowered its prices. It was losing customers to Netflix. Today, pricing and merchandising are as complicated as they’ve ever been. Pricing online requires businesses to manage dynamic pricing systems to keep up with competitors instantly. And yet, because of budget constraints and old habits, Blockbuster executives were stuck with outdated strategies that only had a temporary life span. Zero margin gain.
Blockbuster’s pricing and product strategy
In reality, Blockbuster thought customers wanted to walk into a store to pick up a movie and snacks. It turned out that what customers really wanted was to watch movies and eat snacks without having to leave their houses to rent the film. Then Netflix entered the market by delivering the DVDs right to your doorsteps via mail.
Yes, Blockbuster gave people the option to rent a Hollywood blockbuster movie on DVD rather than buy it – their main value proposition. They also had lots of DVD copies of movies available to rent out repeatedly. Which was a revenue model which exceeded the price of buying one outright. However, their pricing and their value proposition were short-lived. The world moved on and their business model drew quickly to the end of its life cycle.
How Netflix was born
Inspired by the backlash against Blockbuster’s late fees, the Netflix business model was born. When Reed Hastings, founder of Netflix, lost a DVD he rented from Blockbuster. He dreaded paying $40 in late fees for a DVD. An idea came to him: What if you don’t have to pay the late fees AND you don’t have to personally return movies to stores at all? Hence, the creation of the DVD-by-mail. From there-on-in, an innovative concept of online streaming was the logical step from that successful venture.
Then in 2000, Netflix’s co-founder Marc Randolph offered CEO Blockbuster John Antioco a stake in their new company’s online streaming service. In exchange, they wanted to advertise their business in Blockbuster’s physical stores. Antioco laughed at the offer saying it will not work. Streaming was just starting and the technology was relatively new. Little did they realise that, a decade later, Netflix would overtake Blockbuster in terms of entertainment streaming.
Blockbuster, to stem off profit loss, then purchased Movielink in 2007. Movielink is an on-demand digital movie downloads service. It tried to enter the online streaming service but it was too late in the game. It failed to catch on due to the digital-rights management rules it uses to protect copyright material which is too uncompromising. Also, it’s incompatible to burn onto discs.
What were the other reasons why Blockbuster went out of business?
- Evolving competitive field. Other new players were coming in to challenge Blockbuster in the rental business. Not only was the startup company Netflix competing against Blockbuster, but also technological giants like Apple and Amazon. Various cable subscription services were showcasing streaming and video-on-demand, which in turn, was eating into Blockbuster’s profit margin.
- Revising its business model. Transforming Blockbuster’s brick and mortar operations to digital services required a drastic change to its current operating model. The technology change would mean a substantial cut in its revenues. Something the company was not ready to do.
- Losing the opportunity when it had the chance to do so. If Blockbuster had taken the offer from Netflix, it would have taken the lead in streaming movies and in turn earned revenues in the billions. Instead, they stuck to their old business strategy.
- Ignoring what the customers really wanted. Blockbuster didn’t listen to their customer feedback about their pricing scheme or revenue model. The market was changing right before them. Real and honest customer sentiment is really difficult to gauge. Even if customers have no gripes with their actual product, they preferred not to engage with them because of their refusal to listen to them.
An afterthought to its fiasco: Blockbuster had an opportunity to use its huge database of customers’ profiles to understand the market. The recorded data of all the titles that were rented, identifying their preferences and buying habits by customer group could have given them an incredible treasure trove of data on improving their pricing and business model. But they did not have the foresight or skill to use it to their advantage back then.
- Traditional businesses should adapt to transform into the digital world. Brand strength and past successes aren’t enough to compete in the future, especially in this fast-paced technological world.
- Choosing the wrong revenue model – no matter how much incremental EBIT it generates in the short term – will end up accelerating a bad business model to the finish line.
- Overcharging customers for products because there’s limited competition is not a smart pricing strategy in the mid to long term (i.e, 2 – 5 years). If you are the only provider of a product or service remember that there are other businesses out there trying to copy and improve upon good business models. Their obvious strategy when they enter the market will be to penetrate it by undercutting you on the price for the same or similar offer.
- Pretending your business will be the same forever is a recipe for disaster. Nothing lasts forever. It’s how you adapt your business and pricing models to changing times that is the key to economic value generation.
- Always be aware of changing trends in the business world – across all industry, not just your own. Ignoring a shift only makes it worse. New solutions, trends, and buying patterns will always be there even if you choose not to see them.
- Blockbuster’s late fees were its Achilles heel. To the customers, it is like a punishment. This adds stress to the rental process.
- Successful CEOS, such as those at Netflix, Amazon, and other online services emphasise that risky moves require bigger visions, where failure is not a setback but something to learn from it.
Click here to download a free guide to increasing EBIT using price.
For a comprehensive view on maximising growth in your company,
Are you a business in need of help to align your pricing strategy, people and operations to deliver an immediate impact on profit?
If so, please call (+61) 2 9000 1115.
You can also email us at email@example.com if you have any further questions.
Make your pricing world-class!
- marketing strategy (15)
- Organisational Design (13)
- Podcast (114)
- Pricing Capability (60)
- Pricing Career Advice (10)
- Pricing Recruitment (15)
- Pricing Strategy (184)
- Pricing Team Skills (10)
- Pricing Teams & Culture (15)
- Pricing Transformation (18)
- Revenue Model (8)
- Sales Effectiveness (15)
- Talent Management (5)
- Technical Pricing Skills (28)