Are Fast Food Menu Prices Rising Faster Than the Value They Offer? 🥬

McDonald’s used to mean reliable burgers at reliable prices. These days, things are different. Sales are slipping. Prices keep climbing. And customers are questioning the value. Recently, McDonald’s reported a rare global sales drop. In Australia, fast food menu prices have surged — a small Big Mac meal now costs more than $12. The classic six-piece nuggets? Up 22% in just a few years.

Meanwhile, newer fast-casual players like Guzman y Gomez and El Jannah are serving up fresh, flavourful meals at a similar price point—and Australians are taking notice. But this isn’t just McDonald’s story. It’s a cautionary tale for every fast food business. When your pricing no longer aligns with what customers feel they’re getting, trust breaks down. And once you lose trust, you lose sales.

Let’s break down why some chains are losing the value battle—and what they can do about it.

>Download Now: Free PDF How to Improve Your Pricing Team Performance

Brand Loyalty Isn’t Enough to Uphold Fast Food Menu Prices

Years ago, having a big name was enough. You didn’t need to explain your prices. Familiarity kept people coming back.

Today? Not so much. Customers care about more than a logo. They expect quality, fairness, and transparency. Hence, they compare brands. They read reviews. And they talk about their experience online.

Take Guzman y Gomez. It charges prices similar to McDonald’s. But many customers believe they get better food, better service, and more satisfying portions—especially when fast food menu prices keep rising. Even longtime McDonald’s fans say they feel let down by the mcdonald’s value proposition after repeated mcdonalds price increases in recent years.

That’s a brand equity wake-up call. If your prices don’t match the experience, people walk.

What to do: Reassess your value offering. Ask your customers what matters most to them. Taste? Service? Cleanliness? Price? Use that feedback to realign your offer.

Fast Food Price Increases Without Value Additions Backfire

To be fair, costs have gone up for everyone. But raising fast food menu prices without adding anything new? That’s where it hurts.

A $12 Big Mac meal feels steep when a $15 option down the road tastes better and feels more premium. And when the McDonald’s price increase outpaces inflation, customers feel taken advantage of.

This is where many businesses go wrong: they assume people will simply absorb the cost. But when prices rise, so do expectations. And when those expectations aren’t met, disappointment sets in.

What to do: If you must raise prices, show customers the added value. Improve the product, the packaging, the experience—something that justifies the extra dollars.

McDonald’s Food Menu Price Increases and Value Proposition Pushback

In mid-2025, a grassroots group called for a boycott of McDonald’s, accusing the brand of price gouging and unfair labour practices.

That’s not just a PR issue. It’s a reflection of growing frustration. Customers are savvy. They sense when businesses protect margins at their expense—especially when fast food menu prices rise without clear improvements to quality or experience. And they respond by walking, protesting, or simply choosing somewhere else.

Even smaller changes, like McDonald’s inconsistent drink lids in Australia, have sparked confusion and irritation. Loyal customers crave consistency. Sudden changes—especially unannounced—erode confidence and further weaken McDonald’s value proposition.

What to do: Keep your changes consistent and explain them clearly. If there’s a backlash, don’t double down. Listen. Adjust. Communicate.

Affordability, Quality, Consistency: The Winning Trio

Setting fast food menu prices wisely isn’t just about covering costs. It’s about finding a balance between three key things:

1. Affordability – Prices should feel fair and justifiable. When customers feel they’re being overcharged, even slightly, it creates resentment. That emotion is hard to reverse.

2. Quality – It’s not just about food—it’s about service, cleanliness, and the full dining experience. If a $15 meal feels premium, people will pay it. If a $12 meal feels cheap, they won’t.

3. Consistency – Customers expect the same product every time, from taste to packaging. Constant changes create uncertainty, which weakens trust.

What to do: Audit how you’re performing across all three. A drop in any one of them can break the perception of value.

What You Must Do Now

Let’s look at five actionable ways to set better fast food menu prices:

1. Audit Your Value – Don’t just look at your prices—look at what people get for them. Compare your offering with both budget and premium competitors. Identify gaps in perception and reality.

2. Build Tiered Pricing – Not every customer wants the same thing. Offer an entry-level “value” range, a standard mid-tier option, and a premium tier for those willing to pay more. This helps you serve different segments without alienating anyone.

3. Communicate Transparently – Don’t make silent price changes. Be open. Tell customers why prices have changed. Highlight any quality improvements, sustainability efforts, or service upgrades.

4. Monitor Feedback Continually – Don’t wait for a backlash to listen. Use surveys, loyalty programs, and social media insights to stay in touch with sentiment. If customers feel heard, they’ll be more forgiving.

5. Respond With Agility – If something’s not working, change it—fast. KFC, for example, responded quickly to backlash with new value meals. It’s not a sign of weakness—it’s a smart strategy.

〉〉〉 Get Your FREE Pricing Audit  〉〉〉

It’s Time to Rethink Fast Food Menu Prices and Value Proposition

McDonald’s is the headline, but the story is bigger than that. Fast food menu prices have become a flashpoint for customer trust. Price without value loses trust—and trust is hard to rebuild.

Customers today want more than just a recognisable name. They want a good deal, a great experience, and confidence that what they’re buying is worth it. Even a fast food value menu must now live up to higher expectations around quality and consistency.

So ask yourself—are you truly delivering value, or are you relying on habit? Because in today’s market, value wins.

Let’s talk about your pricing. Whether you’re a fast food brand or a business in another industry, value perception affects your bottom line. If you’re unsure how to strike the right balance between affordability and quality, we’d love to help.

Reach out for a chat or send through your questions—let’s make sure your pricing works for both your margins and your customers.

For a comprehensive view of integrating a high-performing pricing team in your company, Download a complimentary whitepaper on How to Improve Your Pricing Team Performance.

Are you a business in need of help aligning your pricing strategy, people and operations to deliver an immediate impact on profit?

If so, please call (+61) 2 9000 1115.

You can also email us at team@taylorwells.com.au if you have any further questions.

Make your pricing world-class!