Costco builds its reputation on low prices, but its price strategy is shifting. Many everyday staples have climbed by up to 59% in the past two years, and membership fees continue to rise: now AU$65 in Australia and US$65 in the U.S. Customers still believe they’re saving, but the numbers tell a more complex story.
Costco may cap margins at around 14%, but that doesn’t always translate to better value for shoppers. Increasingly, people are paying for access, not bargains. The Costco price strategy works because it feels fair, but the gap between perception and reality is widening.
Costco’s value equation is simple: limited choice, minimal service, bulk quantities, and low prices. That once differentiated the brand. However, as inflation settles and expectations rise, shoppers want more than bare-bones efficiency. What once created loyalty can now restrict it. The idea of “value for money” feels less certain, even as Costco products and prices stay central to its pitch.
For retailers and wholesalers who rely on low prices, Costco’s shift matters. It shows how “lowest price wins” is not a long-term strategy, even for membership retail stores. Customers now judge value through convenience, experience, sustainability, and trust — not just cents per unit. This is where any low price marketing strategy risks falling short.
>Download Now: Free PDF How to Drive Pricing Strategy to Accelerate Sales & EBIT Growth
The Mirage of Costco Price Strategy and Low Prices
Prices still look lower on the shelf, but the Costco price strategy increasingly relies on membership revenue, not product margins. Membership income subsidises the low-price promise and absorbs cost pressures. This creates price resilience, but only if customers keep believing the trade-off is worth it in membership retail stores.
Moreover, bulk buying doesn’t always mean better value today. Smaller households, cost-conscious shoppers, and time-poor customers are rethinking whether Costco products and prices, like 3kg of peanut butter or a 12-pack of shampoo, are a “saving” or a burden. This shift raises a tougher question: Is the Costco business strategy still aligned with what modern customers value?
For low-price retailers, this is a warning flare. Value perception can collapse quickly when the product experience no longer matches the price story.
Capability Building Programmes For Pricing & Sales Teams!
How the Access Model Shapes Membership Retail Stores and Costco Price Strategy
Costco pioneered the idea of paying to save, but this structure is now everywhere, from Amazon Prime to loyalty subscriptions across retail. Customers accept memberships when they receive consistent value. But when prices rise, and benefits shrink, the Costco price strategy becomes harder to justify.
The danger is that when customers start evaluating whether access is still worth paying for in membership retail stores, the brand already risks erosion.
For businesses, if your pricing depends on locking customers into a system, the value must grow, not shrink, over time; otherwise, even the strongest low price marketing strategy will fail.
You need the Right Numbers for Pricing! 👍 Podcast Ep. 66!
Value Challenges in Costco Products and Prices
Costco operates with remarkable efficiency: only around 4,000 SKUs, rapid supplier shifts, and strong private-label performance. This keeps costs low and supports the Costco price strategy. But efficiency is not the same as value creation.
Retail customers now seek:
- Ease of use, not just economy
- Smaller, flexible pack sizes, not storage challenges
- Better experiences, not simply transactional buying
- Transparency, not pricing mystique
- Sustainability, not just bulk consumption
Costco’s stripped-back model limits how it can respond. As consumer expectations diversify, even Costco products and prices in a low price marketing strategy or membership retail stores context face challenges.
Kirkland Signature and Its Role in Costco Business Strategy
Kirkland Signature remains Costco’s biggest asset. A single private-label brand simplifies operations and builds trust, supporting the Costco price strategy. However, it also narrows the perception of choice. Customers increasingly compare private labels across retailers, from Coles’ home brands to Aldi’s exclusive labels, where packaging, design, and product storytelling have improved.
Kirkland still performs, but it competes in a more sophisticated private-label landscape. If shoppers feel they can get comparable value elsewhere without paying for membership retail stores, Costco’s advantage narrows. This also puts pressure on Costco products and prices and the broader Costco business strategy.
For retailers, this highlights the importance of brand-led value, not volume-led value.
The Risk in Costco Value Story Misalignment
Every retailer tells a price story. Costco’s story has always been: “We keep margins low, so you save,” forming the core of the Costco price strategy. But when prices rise faster than expectations, even if justified by costs, the story weakens.
The risk isn’t the price rise itself. It’s the loss of clarity in Costco products and prices or the broader Costco business strategy.
When customers start asking, “What am I actually paying for?” the emotional contract breaks long before churn appears, even in membership retail stores or under a low price marketing strategy.
Businesses often underestimate this moment.
Pricing Recruitment For Pricing Managers!
What Pricing Teams Can Learn from Costco Low Price Marketing Strategy
Efficiency helps control costs, but it does not create value on its own. Understanding the Costco price strategy shows that pricing teams must focus on where customers genuinely see worth, not just where the business sees savings.
This means:
- Mapping customer value drivers regularly
- Identifying which parts of the experience hold the most pricing power in membership retail stores
- Building pricing structures around outcomes, not inputs
- Testing value perception before implementing increases, especially for Costco products and prices
In a market where customers question more, clarity becomes currency.
〉〉〉 Get Your FREE Pricing Audit 〉〉〉
Key Takeaways for Executives on Costco Business Strategy
Costco shows that even strong brands face value dilution when conditions shift, highlighting the importance of a clear price strategy. Sustainable advantage comes from expanding value, not compressing it. Low prices alone cannot anchor loyalty forever.
Executives must rethink their price narrative. A brand will stretch, but not indefinitely. Once customers question what they’re paying for, restoring trust costs far more than the price rise itself, even for membership retail stores or a low price marketing strategy.
In the end, businesses that thrive are those that treat value as a living system, not a fixed promise. Value evolves as customers do. Now is the time to check whether your own price story still holds.
If you want support, we’re here to help. We work with businesses to optimise products and prices, build clear pricing frameworks, strengthen value communication, and create resilient models. Reach out anytime. Let’s talk about what your customers truly value and how your business can price with confidence.
For a comprehensive view of maximising growth in your company, download a complimentary whitepaper on How to Drive Pricing Strategy to Accelerate Sales & EBIT Growth.
Are you a business in need of help aligning your pricing strategy, people and operations to deliver an immediate impact on profit?
If so, please call (+61) 2 9000 1115.
You can also email us at team@taylorwells.com.au if you have any further questions.
Make your pricing world-class!
