Competitor Oriented Pricing Is Tempting, But Is It Right for You? 🥇

Recently, Nike announced a price increase of up to $10 on premium footwear—a move that has prompted Adidas and Puma to consider similar adjustments. It’s a classic case of competitor oriented pricing, where strategy is shaped by what others in the market are doing. This scenario raises a critical question for businesses: Should you follow the pricing moves of a market leader, or chart your own course?

>Download Now: Free PDF A Capability Framework for Pricing Teams

Nike Price Increase and the Influence of Market Leader Pricing

Market leaders like Nike often set the tone for industry pricing. Their decisions can create a ripple effect, influencing competitors to adjust their prices accordingly. This phenomenon, known as price leadership, occurs when a dominant firm sets prices that others in the market follow, making way for competitor oriented pricing strategies.

For companies like Adidas and Puma, following Nike’s lead might seem logical, especially when facing similar cost pressures due to tariffs and supply chain challenges. Aligning prices can help maintain competitive parity and avoid being perceived as lower quality.

When Competitor Oriented Pricing Brings Advantages 

There are situations where mirroring a market leader’s pricing strategy can be beneficial:

Shared Cost Pressures: If your business is grappling with the same rising input costs as others in your industry, like tariffs, shipping fees, or materials, it may make sense to adjust prices alongside competitors. This helps protect your margins and signals that your pricing changes are grounded in economic reality, not opportunism.

Market Positioning: When your brand serves a customer base similar to that of the market leader, matching their pricing can strengthen your brand’s perceived value and legitimacy. It helps you stay competitive while reinforcing your place in the same tier of quality or performance.

Consumer Expectations: In certain markets, especially those with commoditised products or tight brand clusters, consumers expect relatively consistent pricing. Straying too far below can cheapen your brand image, while pricing too far above may cause confusion or drive customers away.

When Competitor Oriented Pricing Brings Disadvantages

However, blindly implementing a competitor oriented pricing without considering your unique circumstances can be detrimental:

Margin Erosion: If your business operates with higher costs than the market leader, copying their prices can eat into your profits quickly. What works for them might not be financially sustainable for you.

Brand Dilution: Matching prices without offering similar value or experience can make your brand seem inconsistent or unclear. Customers may start questioning what your brand really stands for.

Loss of Differentiation: When businesses compete mainly on price, they risk turning their products into just another option in a crowded market. Over time, this can weaken brand loyalty and reduce pricing power.

Standing Firm Could Be A Strategic Alternative to Competitor Oriented Pricing

Sometimes, maintaining your current pricing strategy is the wiser choice:

Value-Based Pricing: If your products deliver unique benefits—whether through design, performance, or service—customers are often willing to pay more. This allows you to stay above price-driven competition and focus on value rather than volume.

Customer Loyalty: Customers who have built trust in your brand often value consistency and reliability. Holding prices steady when others are increasing can deepen loyalty and create goodwill that pays off over time.

Market Segmentation: If your audience is highly price-sensitive, moving your prices up with premium brands can backfire. You risk losing customers who don’t see enough added value to justify the increase.

Benchmarking Without Losing Control

To navigate pricing decisions effectively, you need more than just a reactive competitor oriented pricing are doing—you need a grounded, well-informed approach that fits your business.

Conduct Internal Analysis: Start by reviewing your own numbers. Know your cost structures, profit margins, and how each product or service delivers value. Identify which customer segments are most price-sensitive and which are more loyal to your brand. Without this clarity, price changes can lead to unexpected revenue dips or lost trust.

Monitor Competitors: Yes, keep an eye on market leaders and industry movements—they offer useful context. But don’t treat their moves as instructions. Use competitor pricing as a benchmark, not a blueprint. What works for Nike or another brand may not suit your position, customer expectations, or brand promise.

Engage Customers: Talk to your customers or gather feedback through surveys or sales teams. Learn how price changes affect their behaviour and expectations. When customers feel heard, they’re more likely to understand—and accept—your pricing decisions.

Scenario Planning: Play out the “what ifs.” Build simple pricing models or simulations that explore different price points, customer reactions, and cost scenarios. This helps you prepare for multiple outcomes, rather than getting caught off guard. It’s not about predicting the future—it’s about being ready for it.

Steps for Business Leaders and Pricing Teams

Strong pricing doesn’t happen by accident—it’s the result of deliberate investment and collaboration. Especially in uncertain or fast-moving markets, businesses that build pricing capability from within are better equipped to lead rather than follow.

Invest in Pricing Capabilities: Build a team or upskill existing staff to deeply understand pricing. This includes analysing costs, interpreting customer behaviour, and tracking market trends. Internal expertise allows you to move confidently, instead of relying solely on external cues or guesswork.

Foster Cross-Functional Collaboration: Pricing is not just a finance task. Bring marketing, sales, operations, and product teams into the conversation. Each department offers insights—from customer sentiment to supply chain constraints—that help shape smarter, more aligned pricing strategies.

Stay Agile: Markets shift. Tariffs change. Competitors move. Your pricing strategy needs room to flex with the environment. Having clear pricing principles and real-time data makes it easier to adjust without losing sight of long-term goals.

Prioritise Customer Value: At the core of every pricing decision should be this question: What value are we delivering, and how well are we communicating it? When customers see the difference your brand makes, they’re more likely to accept—and even support—your price point.

〉〉〉 Get Your FREE Pricing Audit  〉〉〉

Lead with Strategy, Not Imitation

In uncertain economic times, pricing decisions become even more critical. While competitor oriented pricing and following a market leader can offer a sense of security, it’s essential to base pricing strategies on your business’s unique context and objectives. Conduct thorough analyses and consider the broader implications, so you can make informed decisions that protect your margins, reinforce your brand, and meet your customers’ expectations.

If you’re weighing up whether to follow a market leader’s price move, let’s talk. Every brand has its own path, and sometimes the best move is the one that feels hardest to make. We help businesses find clarity and confidence in complex pricing decisions. Reach out when you’re ready—we are here to support your next step.

For a comprehensive view of integrating a high-performing capability team in your company, Download a complimentary whitepaper on A Capability Framework for Pricing Teams.

Are you a business in need of help aligning your pricing strategy, people and operations to deliver an immediate impact on profit?

If so, please call (+61) 2 9000 1115.

You can also email us at team@taylorwells.com.au if you have any further questions.

Make your pricing world-class!