CarMax’s recent strategy moves raise a big question for every business thinking about sales and pricing. The company is cutting used-vehicle prices and margins while increasing marketing spend as it heads into 2026. This combination is designed to drive sales after a period of weak results. It’s important because it reveals how pricing, demand and customer perception interact in a real-world market. But the strategy also forces us to ask: Does price cutting really increase sales in a sustainable way?
CarMax’s decision comes after several quarters of declining unit sales and softer demand. The firm reported lower revenues alongside a drop in sales volumes, even as it embraced lower price points. That tells us two things. First, customers are sensitive to price. Second, price alone may not be enough to drive behaviour without a clear value message.
>Download Now: Free PDF How to Maximise Margins with Price Trials
The CarMax Pricing, Sales, and Marketing Strategy Shift
CarMax is one of the largest used-vehicle retailers in the United States. Its decision to cut prices and margins is significant. The company is choosing to sacrifice margin in the short term to try to bring customers back. Many businesses see price cuts as a quick lever in sales and pricing. But this isn’t a simple fix.
Price cuts do not automatically generate more sales. That is a common assumption. In practice, many customers interpret discounts differently. Lower pricing can attract more buyers, yes. But it can also signal lower quality or desperation if not paired with a strong value story. The CarMax pricing shift reflects wider used car price trends and shows that price moves alone may not shift behaviour enough when demand is already weak.
Capability Building Programmes For Pricing & Sales Teams!
Sales and Pricing Improve When Targeted Cuts Replace Blanket Discounts
CarMax is not slashing prices across every vehicle. Instead, it is making targeted price adjustments on selected inventory. That matters. Targeted pricing is a demand-based strategy within sales and pricing. It recognises that not every product or customer responds the same way. Some vehicles still command strong interest at current prices. Others sit longer, showing resistance. Targeted cuts help unlock demand where resistance is highest while protecting value where it still exists.
This is good practice. It shows discipline and analysis rather than panic. Price should not be a blunt instrument. It should be a precise tool in the hands of teams who understand demand signals and customer value thresholds. But even targeted cuts carry risk. If sales volumes do not recover quickly enough, margins erode, and profitability can suffer. That is the tightrope businesses walk when they trade margin for volume.
Economic research supports this nuance. Price adjustments respond to market conditions, but they also interact with demand elasticity and competitive signals in complex ways. Simply lowering prices without a clear plan for value communication (one of the core pricing methods and strategies in marketing) often leads to margin leakage rather than behavioural change.
What should a Marketer know about Pricing? 📚 Podcast Ep. 61!
What Is a Good Price for a Used Car? What are the Price Trends?
Lower prices can sometimes fail to move customers. This usually happens when customers do not believe the price represents value. In other words, in sales and pricing, price is only one part of value perception.
Many buyers make decisions based on relative value: how a lower price compares to expectations, alternatives, and perceived risks. If customers suspect a discount is because quality is poor or the seller is desperate, they may hesitate. They might look elsewhere or delay purchasing altogether. This is especially true in markets with abundant information, such as the used-car market, where questions like what is a good price for a used car are shaped by comparison tools and high transparency.
So price cuts can help. But they must be paired with messaging that reinforces trust, quality and relevance. Without that, discounts simply leak margin and fail to shift behaviour.
Marketing’s Real Job in a Sales and Pricing Reset
CarMax’s strategy increases marketing spend to communicate value and regain relevance. That is not a luxury. It is vital. In sales and pricing, marketing serves a specific purpose: it tells customers why the price change matters and why now is the right time to act.
Without clear messaging, customers may not notice price changes or may misinterpret them. That leads to what pricing experts call margin leakage, where price moves occur but do not translate into decisions. If the story behind CarMax pricing is weak, customers still hesitate, and sales do not rise. That leaves the business with lower margins and the same demand challenge.
Stronger marketing does not simply mean more advertising. It means better communication. It means explaining why the price change exists, what value customers get, and how this offer compares to alternatives. When done well, marketing and pricing become reinforcing levers. Together, they shape both perception and behaviour.
What This Means for Pricing Teams
Pricing must be evidence-led and dynamic. This means:
- Measure how different customer segments respond to price changes.
- Use data to understand where demand is elastic and where it is not.
- Track unit response frequently, not just quarterly.
- Test changes on small groups before broad application.
Price is not a static number. It is a signal to the market. In sales and pricing, when teams measure elasticity strategically, they make better decisions. They avoid unnecessary margin loss and can better forecast the volume outcomes of price moves.
This approach is not theoretical. It is practical and actionable. Businesses that understand how price interacts with demand and used car price trends can make more confident decisions. They cut prices in the right places and hold them in the right places. Most of all, they measure the outcome and adjust quickly.
Pricing Recruitment For Pricing Managers!
What This Means for Business Leaders
Pricing cannot work in isolation. It is not a short-term tactic. It is a strategic system. Pricing must align with:
- cost control and operational efficiency,
- clear marketing communication,
- and execution discipline across the business.
Leaders who see pricing as part of a broader system protect long-term value while restoring growth. In sales and pricing, decisions should not be knee-jerk reactions. They should be deliberate, data-backed, and aligned with organisational goals.
This also means investing in pricing capability. Organisations with strong pricing teams, robust data infrastructure, and cross-functional coordination are more resilient. They do not cut prices first and ask questions later. They design price moves that reflect customer behaviour, market conditions, and proven pricing methods and strategies in marketing.
〉〉〉 Get Your FREE Pricing Audit 〉〉〉
Turning Sales Pressure into Smarter Pricing Methods and Strategies in Marketing
CarMax’s strategy points to a simple truth. In sales and pricing, price and marketing must work together, not in isolation. Price cuts can attract attention, but without a clear value story and data-led execution, they erode profit without creating lasting sales.
For pricing teams, this means working with evidence and staying adaptable. For business leaders, it means treating pricing as part of a broader system. When you do, pricing stops being a reaction and becomes a true driver of value.
With the right structure, data, and guidance, sales and pricing become growth tools, not risks. We help businesses turn pressure into clarity and reaction into strategy. Reach out and let’s explore how your pricing, teams, and systems can protect value and unlock sustainable growth.
For a comprehensive pricing strategy to prevent revenue loss in your company, download a complimentary whitepaper on How to Maximise Margins with Price Trials.
Are you a business in need of help aligning your pricing strategy, people and operations to deliver an immediate impact on profit?
If so, please call (+61) 2 9000 1115.
You can also email us at team@taylorwells.com.au if you have any further questions.
Make your pricing world-class!
